13-yr-old case, no Conviction: Pune court acquits five accused of assaulting police officer
Prosecution fails to establish who allegedly manhandled the uniformed officer or how his official duty was obstructed; court cites missing eyewitness support and gaps in identification
4 મિનિટ વાંચન

Prosecution fails to establish who allegedly manhandled the uniformed officer or how his official duty was obstructed; court cites missing eyewitness support and gaps in identification
Pune, Maharashtra Mirror
A police officer's allegation that five men surrounded, abused and manhandled him after he questioned their behaviour on a city road has failed to stand the test of evidence, with a Pune sessions court acquitting all five accused in a case that remained pending for nearly 13 years.
The court found that the prosecution had failed to establish the specific role played by each accused, produce supporting eyewitness testimony or prove how the alleged confrontation actually obstructed the officer from performing his official duty. Merely getting out of a vehicle and arguing with a police officer, the court held, was not enough to establish the offence of obstructing a public servant.
Additional Sessions Judge Shridhar K. Dhekale acquitted Gopal Bansahab Bankhile, Vivek Sudam Thorat, Ajay Popat Thorat, Rama Balasaheb Thorat and Mahendra Balshiram Pingle under Sections 143, 147 and 353 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code. The judgment was delivered on November 7, 2026, in sessions case No. 241/2020.
Prosecution fails to pinpoint roles
According to the prosecution, the incident took place on January 11, 2013, when the complainant, a police sub-inspector, then attached to Bhosari police station, was returning on his motorcycle after completing a training-related duty at the Pune Police Commissionerate.
The officer alleged that a Tavera overtook him near Wakdewadi. A person sitting in the rear allegedly leaned out of the vehicle, abused people travelling on the road and made obscene gestures. When the officer questioned the occupants after the vehicle stopped near the egg-hatching centre junction, five men allegedly got out, surrounded him, abused him and pushed him, asking whether he was trying to become ‘Singham’.
The officer subsequently contacted the control room, following which traffic police intercepted the vehicle while it was proceeding towards Mumbai. A complaint was registered at Khadki police station, leading to the prosecution of the five men for rioting, unlawful assembly and assault or criminal force against a public servant.
However, the court found that the complainant's testimony did not clearly establish which accused had committed which act. The evidence also failed to establish precisely who had allegedly abused him or pushed him.
No witness, no clear proof of obstruction
A key weakness in the prosecution's case was the absence of any independent witness who supported the police officer's account. The court noted that the two other prosecution witnesses were not eyewitnesses to the incident and their testimony did not advance the prosecution's case.
The complainant also admitted during cross-examination that no passer-by had lodged a written complaint about the alleged conduct of the occupants. He further admitted that he had not sustained any injury.
The court also pointed to inconsistencies and gaps in the complaint, including the absence of a clear recording time and the lack of the complainant's signature on the printed complaint.
More importantly, the prosecution failed to establish what specific official duty the officer was performing at the time of the alleged confrontation, how that duty was obstructed or whether he was prevented from carrying it out.
The judge observed that a mere argument with a police officer after getting out of a vehicle could not, by itself, prove that the officer's official duty had been obstructed.
*13 years later, prosecution fails to prove charges
The case was registered on January 11, 2013, and the chargesheet was filed on January 29, 2013. The matter was committed to the Sessions Court in February 2020. Evidence recording began in December 2018, and the final judgment came on November 7, 2026.
Holding that the prosecution had failed to prove the essential ingredients of the offences beyond reasonable doubt, the court acquitted all five accused under Section 235(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
The accused were directed to execute personal bonds of Rs 15,000 each under Section 437-A of the CrPC to ensure their appearance before the appellate court if required. The court also confirmed its earlier order handing over the seized Tavera to its owner.

i am vikrant kulkarni. i am news and vedio editor of maharashtra mirror news paper
