Marvel Dwellings’ 14-Year-Old Flat Promise: MahaRERA Holds Ribera Projects Responsible
In a significant ruling, Authority holds that a change of developer through SARFAESI proceedings cannot wipe out old commitments; Ribera Projects directed to register agreements for two Boat Club Road flats within 60 days and pay interest for delay dating back to 2015
4 min read

LANDOWNERS EXCHANGING LAND FOR FLATS ARE ‘ALLOTTEES’ UNDER RERA: MAHARERA
Landowners entitled to homebuyer protection; new developer cannot escape previous commitments. Ribera Projects directed to register agreements for two Boat Club Road flats within 60 days and pay interest for delay since 2015.
PUNE: Landowners who surrender their property in exchange for apartments in a real estate project are also entitled to protection as ‘allottees’ under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA), the Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (MahaRERA) has ruled in a significant order. The authority has further clarified that a new developer taking over a stalled project through bank recovery proceedings cannot escape the commitments made by the previous developer.
The order, passed on November 19 by MahaRERA Member Ravindra Deshpande, allowed complaints filed by Dilrez Gopal and Farah Zaheer Vakil against Ribera Projects LLP, the current promoter of the stalled Marvel Ribera project on Pune’s prestigious Boat Club Road, along with its partners Suresh Gattani and Ramgopal Bansal.
The dispute originates from a land transaction in 2012 involving a prime plot measuring 4,167.20 square metres on Boat Club Road, which was transferred to Marvel Dwellings Private Limited for a consideration of Rs 65 crore.
Under the agreement, the two complainants were each entitled to Rs 6.50 crore. While Rs 1.50 crore each was paid in cash, the remaining Rs 5 crore was to be adjusted against the allotment of a luxury apartment and parking spaces in the building proposed to be constructed on the land.
The original developer, Marvel Dwellings Private Limited, under the tenure of its then authorised director Vishwajeet Subhash Jhavar, was required to complete the building, obtain the Occupancy Certificate (OC) and hand over possession of the apartments within 30 months of the land conveyance, by March 25, 2015.
However, the commitment remained unfulfilled. Although Flat A-302 was allotted to Dilrez and Flat A-402 to Farah through allotment letters dated December 15, 2022, neither complainant received possession or a registered Agreement for Sale.
Subsequently, the project changed hands following recovery proceedings initiated in connection with claims by ICICI Bank and ICICI Home Finance Company Ltd. After settlement of the financial claims, the project was transferred to Ribera Projects LLP through a registered conveyance deed dated January 9, 2024.
The new developer opposed the complaints, arguing that the women were land sellers with financial claims and not homebuyers under RERA. It further contended that it was not a party to the original transaction and could not be held responsible for the commitments made by the previous developer. The company also argued that the complaints were time-barred.
MahaRERA rejected the central arguments of the developer. It held that since the apartments had been allotted to the complainants as part of the consideration for their land, they qualified as ‘allottees’ under Section 2(d) of RERA. Their status as landowners did not deprive them of the legal protection available under the Act.
The authority also relied on Section 15 of RERA to establish that a change in the promoter does not extinguish the existing obligations attached to a project. A developer taking over a project cannot simply disown the allotments and commitments made by the previous promoter.
AGREEMENTS WITHIN 60 DAYS; INTEREST FROM 2015
MahaRERA has directed Ribera Projects LLP to execute and register Agreements for Sale for both apartments in accordance with the allotment letters dated December 15, 2022, within 60 days.
The respondents have also been directed to bear the applicable stamp duty, registration charges, taxes and other related expenses.
In a significant financial direction, the authority ordered the respondents to pay interest for the delay from March 26, 2015, until actual possession is handed over along with the Occupancy Certificate.
The interest will be calculated at the State Bank of India's highest Marginal Cost of Funds-based Lending Rate (MCLR) plus 2%, in accordance with the Maharashtra RERA Rules. However, the respondents will receive the benefit of the COVID-19 moratorium period under the relevant MahaRERA notifications.
Since the project's registration has lapsed, the developer has also been directed to initiate the process of seeking an extension within 30 days. Failure to comply with the directions may attract a penalty under Section 63 of RERA.
Additionally, the respondents have been directed to pay Rs 20,000 each towards costs.




